Proper roof maintenance is essential for extending its longevity. One of the best ways to bring your roof back to life and restore its efficiency is roof coating. However, in some instances, especially if structural damage has occurred, it’s better to consider complete roof replacement. Both options have their benefits and drawbacks, making it hard to decide.
In this blog post, we compare commercial roof coating vs roof replacement, looking at their pros and cons, and explore when each solution is the right choice.

Key Distinctions Between Roof Coating and Roof Replacement

Both roof coating and replacement make your roof look new, but they’re entirely different projects. Roof coating means adding a durable protection layer that adheres to the roof’s surface, protecting it from external elements. It refreshes the roof’s performance and appeal and prevents leaks, thus saving you money on frequent repairs.
Silicone roof coating is watertight and available in brush-applied and sprayed forms. It’s an affordable solution for quick fixes on premature roof failures.
Replacement means entirely or partially removing the existing structure and installing a new roof. It’s a tedious process that may cost a lot, but it has numerous benefits for the occupants, both health-wise and financial-wise. With a new roof, there’s no need for frequent repairs for a long time, and your home is safe from water intrusion and its consequences.

Benefits and Drawbacks of Roof Coating and Roof Replacement

Roof coatings are easy and quick to install, affordable, eco-friendly, and energy-efficient. Most importantly, they effectively protect your home by being resistant to leaks and reflecting UV rays.
However, roof coating can be used only on smooth or semi-smooth roofing material and when there are minor surface issues. Also, it may require significant preparation and must be applied when the weather is sunny and warm because the roof surface must be dry.
Roof replacement, on the other hand, is the perfect solution for damaged or aged roofs and roofs with structural issues like mold and sagging roof lines. It strengthens your house’s construction and extends its lifespan. A new roof is resistant to heat and cold, guaranteeing your home’s energy efficiency.

But all these long-term benefits come at a high cost. Installing a new roof is quite expensive and may take time.

6 Things to Consider When Deciding Between Coating and Replacing Your Roof

When deciding between roof coating and roof replacement, you need to take into account the following factors:

• The roof’s age
• The roof’s condition
• Your budget
• The cost of each option
• The pros and cons of each roofing solution
• Whether roof coating is applicable
• Your home’s condition

You should choose roof coating if your roof material is smooth or semi-smooth and has no active leaks, moisture, mold, or damage that affects its structural integrity.
You should replace part or all of your roof when it is significantly damaged by leaks, mold, algae growth, large cracks, or sagging roof lines or when it simply cannot be repaired.

Not Sure Which Roofing Solution Is the Right Choice? Call the Foam Co Roofing Pros!

Both roof coating and replacement are great options for maximizing your roof’s effectiveness and extending its longevity. However, they are different in their features and applicability, each being used for specific roof conditions.
Consider their cost, features, applicability, budget, and roof condition, among other factors. If you need help assessing your roof’s condition and choosing the right roofing option, call our team of experts.
At Foam Co Roofing, we strive to provide a stellar customer experience and work hard to satisfy your roofing needs. Whether you need a roof inspection, coating, or a new roof, our skilled technicians are at your service.

Don’t delay; get in touch today!